Over rated: cantaloupe
Under rated: mango (completely agree with Hip, it's the best fruit EVARRRRR)
I eat a lot of random tropical fruits because of my heritage and they're all extremely under rated as well. Durian? Smells like death, but holy **** it's good.
as for me...
overrated: honeydew. ;)
underrated: rainier cherries.
oh and hip, which kind of guava?
my mom doesn't like these:
but she does like these a lot:
she even has a tree of them in her backyard. she eats it with ground up chili salt.
i've been craving fruit ever since i got knocked up so i got some lychees at the market today. mangos are great, too.
I hate mangos, they taste like barf.
Puck, we had a soursop tree while growing up, good stuff. Same genus as the Cherimoya.
Lunchie, at another house growing up I had a strawberry guava tree.
Overrated: Tomato, not a big fan.
Underrated: Starfruit or Mountain Apple
In all seriousness, seeing tomatoes as overrated is very interesting to me. I hated them forever but a couple months ago, i found a appreciation in them and now cant get enough of them in sandwiches, burgers etc.