Depends on if you are craving Chocolate or not.
I just discovered Reese's Peanut Butter Whoppers.
Dairy Queen has a blizzard right now made with the tagalongs girl scout cookies. I tried that tonight. I liked the crunch you got with the cookie pieces but it needed more peanut butter taste like you get with the Reese's blizzard.
PB Cups are my favorite....but the US version is much better then their Canadian Counterparts.
As long as it's Reeses, hell yes. Especially the Big Cups. All non-Reeses PB cups have never done it for me though.
Reese's, hell yes! There's some in the fridge right now.
Reese's loves you back.