Thread: Belfour, Gilmour, Howe and Nieuwendyk headed to the Hall

Originally Posted by gescom

not to veer too off topic, i think Robert Downey Jr. deserved it.

Originally Posted by Dr. Naysay

OK.... I can accept the argument that Downey Jr. gave an equally deserving performance... but let's not go saying Ledger wasn't ****ing amazing.

Originally Posted by gescom

like i said... a legit argument against.


and honestly, i thought it was good... if you want to see Ledger in what i think was a f***ing amazing performance, watch the Lords of Dogtown.

Originally Posted by Dr. Naysay

No.

I was with you Ges...till you brought up RDJ in what I have to believe was Tropic Thunder. Ummm NO. I would like to see who else was nominated cause clearly there was a better choice. And yes, Ledger's job in Lords of Dogtown was pretty good...oscar worthy, prolly not.