Thread: Rick Nash traded to Rangers

The first round picks from the Rangers and us could easily be the last two picks in next years draft. I dont care what Sather said about untouchables, everything is negiotable. Perhaps, Sather told Howson he owed him a favor since the Oilers hired him to run Cape Breton and then Tulsa when Slats left for Broadway. Howson should have gotten at least one of the big 4/5 we have been discussing.

If Dubinsky and Ansimov put up numbers, and Erixson develops, perhaps CBJ did alright, but sure a lot of question marks for Nash, the #1 overall pick his draft year.

This is almost as big a failure by CBJ as the Gretzky trade was for us.

The bottom line is... who cares? Some people are living in the future and nothing has happened yet.

Originally Posted by gretzky99

they do have 3 first round picks next year so i think that is their one hope. if they can draft #1 overall (which they should) and that guy is a franchise player, and then they get two other quality players in the first round, then maybe.

Jones is the favored #1 Pick next summer, and is as highly touted a defenseman as they come. The problem is, they would **** him up too.

Originally Posted by gretzky99

their goaltending is terrible, but as we have all seen, one guy makes all the difference. i don't think that guy is in their organization right now, but finding a goaltender is possible.

Mason was that guy, and they broke him.

Originally Posted by gretzky99

their defense isn't that bad. yes, they overpaid Wiz by a lot. but they have a lot of talent on the blue line with Johnson, Murray, Nikitin and possibly Erixon.

Their defense is headed by 2 guys that aren't known for playing defense.

Originally Posted by gretzky99

i think you are 100% right that they are terrible and have been managed poorly, but with 3 first round picks and a couple of quality guys on the roster, all is not lost.

That will depend on whether or not Howson is still there come next spring.

Originally Posted by gretzky99

and no, Stoll/Penner/1st wouldn't have done it. Columbus got two guys in their early 20s that are established NHL players already plus another promising (albeit suspect) prospect and a 1st. both Stoll and Penner have likely seen their best hockey already and although very valuable players to the Kings, they don't help Columbus in the future. i would think we'd be looking at something more like Lewis, King, Voynov & 1st and i'm not sure that would have done it.

No, but if you want to match returns, we could have done it with Lewis, Clifford, Voynov, and a 1st, which is actually a better return that what New York gave up. Alas, we weren't on Nash's list, which is the problem. Howson was too nice to the player.

Originally Posted by Bluejay

WOW, just WOW. Howson is a complete moron. How he didnt get one, if not more of Krieder, Del Zotto, Stepan or McDonagh is mind-boggling.

It gets better as the BJ's send NYR a 3rd round pick and a minor league D-man

I don't think Howson was ever going to get Kreider, but if I were him I would have told Nash, "I don't care how badly you want to leave, until the Rangers pony up a suitable replacement, your address is in Columbus."

Should have definitely gotten Stepan or McDonagh in this deal. From what I understand San Jose was willing to send Pavelski and Clowe to Columbus. Even if that's not true, how is Pavelski + from San Jose not better than what Howson got from New York?

Originally Posted by Telefunken

This is almost as big a failure by CBJ as the Gretzky trade was for us.

The first one or the second one?

Originally Posted by Birdman

Jones is the favored #1 Pick next summer, and is as highly touted a defenseman as they come. The problem is, they would **** him up too.



Mason was that guy, and they broke him.



Their defense is headed by 2 guys that aren't known for playing defense.



That will depend on whether or not Howson is still there come next spring.



No, but if you want to match returns, we could have done it with Lewis, Clifford, Voynov, and a 1st, which is actually a better return that what New York gave up. Alas, we weren't on Nash's list, which is the problem. Howson was too nice to the player.

it will be interesting to see what they do at the draft. maybe if Jones is that highly touted, they could trade down and pick up an extra pick or two and draft a forward?
i actually don't think Mason was ever going to be that good. once the book got out on him he was toast.
yeah, they need to find a couple of d-mined d-men, but those guys are a little easier to get.
hopefully for C-Bus fans, Howson won't be there next year.

i don't know if Lewis, Clifford, Voynov + first is better than what NYR gave. both Dubinsky and Anisimov are proven scorers in the NHL. Lewis and Clifford are not. Voynov is better than Erixon right now, but Erixon might be considered to have a higher ceiling (not that it matters much).

Originally Posted by KINGS17

I don't think Howson was ever going to get Kreider, but if I were him I would have told Nash, "I don't care how badly you want to leave, until the Rangers pony up a suitable replacement, your address is in Columbus."

Should have definitely gotten Stepan or McDonagh in this deal. From what I understand San Jose was willing to send Pavelski and Clowe to Columbus. Even if that's not true, how is Pavelski + from San Jose not better than what Howson got from New York?

i agree that Howson could have held out for more, but with Johnson and Wiz on defense, is another offensive d-man like McDonagh the guy you want as the centerpiece of the deal?
and if the proposed deal was Pavelski, a young d-man like Demers and a first, i don't necessarily think that is much better. CLM has proven that one scorer isn't going to make them a better team. they got two forwards that will play right away in their top-9.

now, if the offer was Pavelski + Clowe + first, then he took the wrong deal.

but i do think the deal should have been Stepan, Anismov, Erixon + 1st. Dubinsky was likely included because his cap hit is $4.2M.

Originally Posted by KINGS17

Even if that's not true, how is Pavelski + from San Jose not better than what Howson got from New York?

It is but we don't know anything about what he was offered. Period. Rumors are just fodder for the internet.

I just can't judge Howsen (or any GM) that is put in that place by a star player. The trading team will lose pretty much every time.

Howsen has been a poor GM but I base that on his record (which, BTW, should include some nods toward McClean before him). So having 2 or 3 1st rounders next year isn't going to help much if the same management is running the show. Isn't Patrick on their payroll now? Davidson? I'd make them GM?Pres and move on.

jom