So apparently the umps were in the wrong last night and Broxton should not have been forced to leave the game.
SFGate: San Francisco Giants : The Splash : Umpires' error in last night's game
Henry Schulman just spoke to a league official who said the umpires in last night's Dodgers-Giants game erred in forcing Jonathan Broxton from the game.
The official said that the rule requiring a pitcher to be removed after two mound visits should have been superseded by a comment underneath Rule 8.06 that says if two mound visits occur while the same batter is up, the umpires must eject the manager and require the pitcher to face that batter. Only then, should the pitcher be removed.
The mistake was discovered as the umpiring crew engaged in its normal postmortem with league umpiring evaluators.
Had the Dodgers protested the game, there is a chance the protest would have been upheld, and the game replayed. But the league official said the Dodgers neglected to protest the game.
Read more: SFGate: San Francisco Giants : The Splash : Umpires' error in last night's game