Page 43 of 104 FirstFirst ... 3341424344455393 ... LastLast
Results 421 to 430 of 1037
  1. #421
    Let the kids play ASUcruz's Avatar




    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Posts
    11,858
    Liked
    21 times
    Karma
    1000000
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Quoted
    0 Post(s)

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Claw21 View Post
    Kemp will hit 30-45 home runs a year, Kershaw will be the stud that will leave us shaking our heads, and LaRoche will be a solid 3rd baseman (the likes of Ron Cey) . All this will happen within 3 yrs.

    If Ned wants to trade these 3 and be known as just another dumbass Dodger GM, who traded away great talent, then so-be-it.

    Miguel isn't worth all 3.
    Or Matt Kemp could be the next Raul Mondesi, extremley talented player but he never learned to control the strike zone and he always had attitude problems.

    People were saying the exact same things about Edwin Jackson and Greg Miller regarding Kershaw. Granted, Kershaw has been developed far better than either guy and his results have been great. But you never know. With Miguel Cabrera you do know what your getting.

    LaRoche could be a solid 3B for the next decade, but Joel Guzman was a can't miss player as well.

    I love our prospects but to go out and assume that they're all can't miss studs is foolish. I know for a fact Miguel Cabrera is a stud. And like Frolov mentioned in that deal we still keep Loney, Martin, Billingsley, etc. Kershaw is probably the dealbreaker, I can understand if Ned doesn't trade him and I understand if he does. This isn't some decent veteran player. It's Miguel Cabrera, I can't stress this point enough.

  2. #422
    I get around




    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Posts
    6,242
    Liked
    0 times
    Karma
    1000000
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Quoted
    0 Post(s)

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by ASUcruz View Post
    Your talking as if Miguel Cabrera is some **** player. This isn't exactly Pedro Martinez for Delino DeShields.
    You might, or might not, remember my mentioning Cabrera in trade talks very early in the season. Kevin Kennedy is the first one that I heard mentioning trading for him. When I mentioned it on the boards, I think it was just overlooked especially after Marlins Brass said that they weren't fielding any offers for him.
    Even up until the trading deadline, it appeared that the Marlins were still not fielding any offers for him.

    Yet now, they are. I'm happy. I've been a Cabrera fan these past 2 or 3 seasons. I like what he brings. My comment was more of a shot against Nomar Garciapopup, the would-be third baseman had he not completely tanked for good and made us regret the 2-year deal, than a shot against Miggy.

  3. #423
    irisher
    Guest

    Default

    You guys do realize Miguel Cabrera is 24 years old, and one of the top 3 right handed hitters in baseball,who's won a World Series and consistently produced elite numbers before even reaching his prime years?

    I'd like to resign him to make the deal better, but consistently waiting for prospects to become All Stars isn't the way to go. Torre's here to win now.

    I don't know how I'd feel about it, but I wouldn't write this off as selling the farm--we'd still have a lot of under 25 blue chippers in the system and we'd be getting Miguel freaking Cabrera, who would immediately--immediately--become the biggest offensive threat this organization's had since Piazza in the mid-90s.

  4. #424
    encinododgerfan
    Guest

    Default

    Hello everybody. In my starvation for Dodger-talk I've spent the morning reading all 24 pages of this thread. I'm now content! :-)

    I gotta say, I was really hoping for the trade of Pierre and Meloan for Garland, but the Angels broke my heart there. Is there anyone out there who might want Pierre now?? I'm hoping the Dodgers sign Torii Hunter and Rowand goes back to the Sox. Perhaps then we could get Texas to take Pierre. Pierre, D.J. Houlton and Meloan might draw us Hank Blalock to play third. He's a free agent in 2009, so we could continue to develop LaRoche, and make the decision for 2009 later. LaRoche could also be moved to 2B and replace Kent in 2009. Of course, I only say that because of the Dodgers seeming reluctant to had the job to Andy.

    I must say, I'm almost 100% trading for Miguel Cabrera. The cost is just too high. I think that Kemp is going to be a more athletic version of Miguel Cabrera anyway. Trade him, and a potential ace in Kershaw AND, in my opinion, the next Ron Cey in Andy LaRoche?? I'm just not OK with that.

    If I were the GM right now, I'd do my best to sign Hunter, find any way to unload Pierre (for anything, really!), re-sign Wolf and let Nomar and LaRoche battle it out for 3B. If Kent doesn't come back, I'd let Delwyn Young start at 2B and keep Abreu in reserve. I'd work on extending Furcal and try and trade Hu for some pitching. If LaRoche beats out Nomar in Spring, and if Nomar isn't content in a super-utility role, I'd trade him and cash for a mid-level prospect or some bullpen help.

    I can live with...

    Furcal - SS
    Martin - C
    Loney - 1B
    Hunter - CF
    Kemp - RF
    Ethier - LF
    D. Young - 2B
    LaRoche - 3B

    (Doesn't this lineup remind you of the Diamondbacks last year? Veteran leadership in Furcal and Hunter and young talent busting at the seems!)

    And a rotation of...

    Penny
    Lowe
    Billingsley
    Wolf
    Loiaza

    If Schmidt can come back, the rotation is even stronger. Plus, you can look at possible mid-season additions to the rotation of McDonald, Kershaw, Kuo.

    Oh...I fell so much better with that off my chest. :-)

  5. #425
    Hoya
    Guest

    Default

    Hey EDF, weren't you defending Pierre a few months ago and comparing him to Maury Wills?

    Glad you're back though, man. Always good to get another in here who knows his stuff.
    Last edited by Hoya; November 20th, 2007 at 10:08 AM.

  6. #426
    encinododgerfan
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by irisher View Post
    I'd like to resign him to make the deal better, but consistently waiting for prospects to become All Stars isn't the way to go. Torre's here to win now.
    If this orginization is still committed to the young talent it has, I gotta believe that Torre knew that coming in. I think he's here because he want's to prove he can win without the $200 million dollar payroll. I think he knows of the talent on this team, and he believes he can harness the talent of young players into winners like he did with Jeter, Mo, Bernie, etc. I certainly don't think he'd take the job based on promises that we'd sign and/or trade for big-name players.

    Torre seems more concerned with the rotation than adding a BIG bat. Take a look at the 1996 Yankees team and I can see why. They didn't have astronomical power. Bernie Williams led that team with 29 homers. Only one other player (Tino Martinez) had over 20.

  7. #427
    1st Scoring Line Claw21's Avatar




    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Posts
    1,355
    Liked
    49 times
    Karma
    1005000
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Quoted
    28 Post(s)

    Default

    Encino, good to have you over from dodgerdogs.com. I don't know what happened to that site. It got quiet over there real quick.

    Unfortunately, I think the Dodgers are stuck with Pierre. Hands down the most ridiculous FA signing. I'll do back flips if some GM takes us off our hands.

  8. #428
    Hoya
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Claw21
    Encino, good to have you over from dodgerdogs.com. I don't know what happened to that site. It got quiet over there real quick.
    The only good posters (minus maybe one or two) over there also post over here now, so I think most of us would just rather one-stop-shop here.

  9. #429
    encinododgerfan
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by irisher View Post
    You guys do realize Miguel Cabrera is 24 years old, and one of the top 3 right handed hitters in baseball,who's won a World Series and consistently produced elite numbers before even reaching his prime years?

    I'd like to resign him to make the deal better, but consistently waiting for prospects to become All Stars isn't the way to go. Torre's here to win now.

    I don't know how I'd feel about it, but I wouldn't write this off as selling the farm--we'd still have a lot of under 25 blue chippers in the system and we'd be getting Miguel freaking Cabrera, who would immediately--immediately--become the biggest offensive threat this organization's had since Piazza in the mid-90s.
    Quote Originally Posted by jbruin152 View Post
    Hey EDF, weren't you defending Pierre a few months ago and comparing him to Maury Wills?

    Glad you're back though, man. Always good to get another in here who knows their stuff.

    Thanks jbruin. It feels good to be back. I feel bad advocating for Pierre's exit, because I do think he get's a bum-rep. But there is no real way to argue that keeping Pierre over Ethier or Kemp is the way to go. If the Dodgers add a bat by signing Hunter/Rowand/Jones, Pierre is the logical odd-man-out. And with his contract, and the availability of free-agent center-fielders, and his bum-rep, he's going to be hard to unload.

  10. #430
    irisher
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by encinododgerfan View Post
    If this orginization is still committed to the young talent it has, I gotta believe that Torre knew that coming in.
    But even if we get rid of Kemp, Kershaw, and LaRoche, here's a partial look at our under 25 talent:

    Martin
    Ethier
    Loney
    Bills
    Meloan
    Broxton
    Abreu
    Young
    Hu
    Miguel Freaking Cabrera (he's 24)

    We'd still be "committed" to young talent.

    Again, I'm ambivalent about this prospective deal. It's the one that puts me on the fence. Losing Bills and Kershaw or Loney and Kemp would be too much. But not giving up at two of those four will not be enough to get Miggy.

    But I think ASU said it best: I'm not going to be up in arms if we make it. Nor will I be hating life if we don't, as I'd love to see what the kids do next year.

Page 43 of 104 FirstFirst ... 3341424344455393 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28