I'm definitely happy with the game.
While I can understand why some people would have complaints about it, I have to say it's pretty damn fun. Not sure if it's mostly due to the roster matching the period when I was way into wrestling as a kid or just that it's a good, fun arcade wrestling game. Sure, the controls are quirky, but there are a lot of moves you can pull off once you get used to them and it really doesn't take that long. Keep in mind what you're probably used to (Smackdown vs Raw controls) is quirky in its own way.
The integration of the Wrestlemania footage is a big plus, and so is the create-a-legend option. I went in to mess around a bit and ended up making a pretty decent Sid Justice. Now I just need to rent SvR09 to import all the current wrestlers over...
Who's up for some head-to-head over Xbox Live? ::glares at supercalo2000::