Wow, there sure is a lot of love for Blake. The guy who started us into a rebuild, ended it too soon, and now we're stuck in the mushy middle with no impact prospects on the horizon. We're Islanders West minus the #1 overall pick.
Hopefully Holland can be as good as the GM who left us capped out with dollar tree goalies, missing a right hand scoring forward for 2 years, and never weaponized cap space when it was decided to tank.
We're replacing one middle of the pack GM with another. It's the generally uninspired move that is a hallmark of the past decade in Kings history.
How is being sceptic regarding Holland a sign of "love for Blake"? His cap era track record simply isn't great and he failed to bring the Cup to a team with 2 of the best players in the world. What can Ken do with Kopi and DD? We'll see, but celebrating his hire is IMO premature.
This.
Coming from a guy who hates this team every day since 1982, some of you are acting that without a prospect pool, we are doomed and forget who our past GM's were. Yes we are at the lower end now, but even in our cup years we had a lame prospect pool. Shoot, we have always had a bad prospect pool.
Plus our good prospects just started playing with the team and we will add more prospects in the draft.
Every gm makes mistakes like Campbell. He was coming off a 31-9 year. Of course you are going to hope he continues that sucess with you. At the time Edm fans were thrilled. Nobody was expecting for him to implode. That is not on Holland.
His success outweighs his failures. You cannot really say that about our GM history outside of Deano pre 2015. Holland did not destroy a team like George Maguire did for us. He did not make the ridiculous decisions like McMaster did. He did not sign Kovalchuk to a 3 year deal or give Petersen and extenstion. Holland has a pretty damn good resume over the time the league has changed. That is pretty damn remarkable.
This team is young and still the best part of this team. Doughty and Kopi anymore are just parts now who are basically done and we will have cap space to play with and the cap is going up.
This team just needs tinkering and they can be awesome/competitive for a long time.
Calm down. Please.
I think most of us who aren't thrilled with Holland aren't panicking or grinding our pitchforks. We're simply observing the hire as underwhelming, "safe" choice that will most likely continue the mediocrity of this team...
It's the same old "old boys" kind of hire. Rob was "gifted" a rookie GM job and all things considered IMO he learned very well over time and was criticized too much given his inexperience - it was foolish to expect a lot as fans, despite the core being in their prime. But from the perspective of Luc it was quite foolish to hire Rob considering the goal was also "win ASAP".
So at this point most of us expected another "old boys" hire, sure, but I'm disappointed it isn't Futa. He would IMO signal a retool approach, while Holland quite clearly signals a win-now approach.
And regarding win-now approach - I'm afraid Holland was "bailed" out very, very often with McDrai in his Edmonton tenure...and before that - have you seen the last Detroit team that reached the Finals (1 year after they won the Cup)? Prime Datsyuk, Zetterberg, Hossa, Franzen, Kronwall, Samuelsson, Cleary with still great Lidstrom, Rafalski, Holmstrom, Draper...that's the team he managed to assemble in a LONG period of time with a lot of them drafted and mentored in the pre-cap era full of established winners (players like Yzerman, Fedorov, Shanahan, Hull, Chelios...).
And after their last Finals appearance it all went downhill for them (slowly, but surely).
So considering Holland simply won't have generational talents like McDrai at his disposal, with the only other Finals/Cup winning reference being super-stacked Detroit Red Wings - why ARE you optimistic? What do you think he can do?
Unless he pulls several aces out of his sleeves in a short amount of time (which would mean a couple of very good UFA signings AND a very good trade) along with Greentree making an immediate impact it just doesn't look very well when it comes to "win-now" strategy. That's why I'd be much more at peace with another retool to bridge this team towards the end of DD+Kopitar era...
"Fun" thoughts time: Ken gives Gavrikov 8 million for 6 years, Kuzmenko 6 million for 5 years and Kempe 11 for 8 years and trading Greentree, Mikey and a 1st for Morgan Rielly. I consider this scenario much more likely than him pulling 3 great aces out of his sleeves.
I'd LOVE to be wrong though...