Home Cookin' The BBQ/Smokers/Smoked Meats Thread...

I haven't read through this entire thread, but now that I have a house, with a backyard, it is time to pick up a smoker! I was at Costco and saw the Traeger Pellet Smoker, the mid size one was $350. I've been researching them a bit and read a bunch of reviews, they seem to hover around the 3.5-4 star rating. What are your guys' thoughts on Pellet Smokers?
 
I haven't read through this entire thread, but now that I have a house, with a backyard, it is time to pick up a smoker! I was at Costco and saw the Traeger Pellet Smoker, the mid size one was $350. I've been researching them a bit and read a bunch of reviews, they seem to hover around the 3.5-4 star rating. What are your guys' thoughts on Pellet Smokers?
[MENTION=1]Rinkrat[/MENTION] loves his traeger, i havent tried one before. They should be a breeze to use. Grab a good thermometer for the bbq and for the food and you will be good to go. There is a pretty good chance the therm that comes on whatever bbq you buy will not be accurate.
 
i should have never clicked on this thread.
200.gif

I do plan on buying a smoker once i have space for one.
 
I haven't read through this entire thread, but now that I have a house, with a backyard, it is time to pick up a smoker! I was at Costco and saw the Traeger Pellet Smoker, the mid size one was $350. I've been researching them a bit and read a bunch of reviews, they seem to hover around the 3.5-4 star rating. What are your guys' thoughts on Pellet Smokers?

Hey beedee, replied to your PM. The Jr is a good sz for my family of 3. They are an awesome smoker, easy to control. The only thing i changed was i added an ortech controller. Even more precise controls. Johnny Triggs always says that pellet smokers do not part enough flavor, but as an amateur, it does not get any easier and i can walk away from it for the duration of the smoke for the most part. Some of the more exotic pellets such as alder may be a bit tougher to come by and costco has been selling a blend lately and not specific such as mesquite, hickory or apple. Check out pelletheads.com and there you will find everything u want to know about smokers.
 
so, I got thrown down by my supe at work. he is challenging me to a beer-can chicken smoke-off.

#1: he "inherited" a 22 in. Weber Master-Touch from his aunt. it was hardly ever used.
#2: he plans to do a 6-hour smoke time.
#3: this would be his first time smoking anything.

6 hours in a Weber grill like that? I foresee a disaster. I wanted to tell him that, but this being a comp, I figure to wait and see if he is going to crash and burn as predicted.

1-2 hours are all I need. I bring my own smoker. it's a WSM 14.5. it will be rolling smoke at 300+ degrees. and beer-can chicken is something of a myth, but I'll let that slide as I'm going to watch him shove a can right up his chicken's butt. I have my own chicken stand that came with a cup low enough to allow the convection air to flow through the cavity as it is supposed to.

will post results on Friday.
 
I'm telling you now, marinade it in your spices but add 3 cans of PBR and let it go for at least 48 hours. Makes the meat sooooooooooo moist and tender
 
so, I got thrown down by my supe at work. he is challenging me to a beer-can chicken smoke-off.

#1: he "inherited" a 22 in. Weber Master-Touch from his aunt. it was hardly ever used.
#2: he plans to do a 6-hour smoke time.
#3: this would be his first time smoking anything.

6 hours in a Weber grill like that? I foresee a disaster. I wanted to tell him that, but this being a comp, I figure to wait and see if he is going to crash and burn as predicted.

1-2 hours are all I need. I bring my own smoker. it's a WSM 14.5. it will be rolling smoke at 300+ degrees. and beer-can chicken is something of a myth, but I'll let that slide as I'm going to watch him shove a can right up his chicken's butt. I have my own chicken stand that came with a cup low enough to allow the convection air to flow through the cavity as it is supposed to.

will post results on Friday.

I suppose if he smokes it at 200 degrees it might take 6 hours but even that low i dont think it would take that long.
 
I suppose if he smokes it at 200 degrees it might take 6 hours but even that low i dont think it would take that long.

If he does it that low, the beer won't even come to a boil, and he won't get the moisture that this type of cooking is all about. I don't think there is any right way to do this at 6 hours. He's going to end up with chicken jerky and warm beer.

And BeerMan...I've made beer can chicken successfully dozens of time using just the can. I use a nice big can of Foster's Premium Ale (green can). A few reasons I do: they are always sold as a single can; this one is darker, and I prefer dark beers; the can is larger and makes a nice seal, which traps that moisture inside for a really nice stream. I just drink half of it, throw some herbs and spices in the remainder, maybe some bbq sauce too, and get to cooking. Never, ever takes 6 hours lol.
 
Personally i think beercan chicken is a bunch of hooey. Spatchcock a properly brined and seasoned bird and you will have better chicken in less time.
 
Personally i think beercan chicken is a bunch of hooey. Spatchcock a properly brined and seasoned bird and you will have better chicken in less time.

This is something I've yet to do, but is definitely on the must-try list. You split the bird yourself?
 
I have one of those wire stands that I use for vertical roasting. It works well. I've also used cans with some success, but I usually dump most of the beer and also split the can into shreds so it can allow air flow.

6 hours for chicken seems way too long. works better when you run hot (325 - 350) indirect heat for a vertical (beercan) roast taking care not to burn the skin. At that heat, you'll be done in an 1 Hr - 1.5 Hrs. tops.

If you spatchcock it, same thing as above, but then give the skin side a sear over the direct heat when you finish cooking it to get a nice crispy skin.

Another couple things that I picked up along the way: Dry rub under the skin when you can and use a mayo slather on the skin before you apply your rub. Don't know the science, but do know it helps.
 
thanks for the inputs, guys.

I've beer-canned, spatchcocked, and roasted the chicken and cornish hens.

deep-fried? nope, but let's save that for another time.

today, the supe changed his tune. obviously, he did his homework. 3 hours planned. in that Weber. at over 300 degrees.

I nodded and smiled.

then he asked if I have my own beer-can stand.

I nodded.

did you make your own?

nope.

where did you get it?

uhm Amazon I think? my wife got it for me.

ah, dammit.
 
Last edited:
supe: so, we'll have Corey (the shop lead) be the judge.

me: cool. hmmm... how much are you paying him off?
 
Personally i think beercan chicken is a bunch of hooey. Spatchcock a properly brined and seasoned bird and you will have better chicken in less time.

I agree. I haven't broke that to him at all.

here's what's gonna happen: I'm brining my chicken in water, salt, dark brown sugar, and beer. I have no plans to actually use the beer-can method except to make it look like so. there will be a rub applied to it.
 
I have one of those wire stands that I use for vertical roasting. It works well. I've also used cans with some success, but I usually dump most of the beer and also split the can into shreds so it can allow air flow.

6 hours for chicken seems way too long. works better when you run hot (325 - 350) indirect heat for a vertical (beercan) roast taking care not to burn the skin. At that heat, you'll be done in an 1 Hr - 1.5 Hrs. tops.

If you spatchcock it, same thing as above, but then give the skin side a sear over the direct heat when you finish cooking it to get a nice crispy skin.

Another couple things that I picked up along the way: Dry rub under the skin when you can and use a mayo slather on the skin before you apply your rub. Don't know the science, but do know it helps.

Some things I do for my Thanksgiving turkey that kind of plays into all this (should work for chicken, right?):

- Make a compound butter before hand (usually butter with some herbs like sage, savory and thyme mixed in, then formed, cooled and left to meld flavors while the next step happens). I usually make 2 or 3 sticks' worth;
- Brine the bird (for minimum 2 days, but usually 3 to 4);
- Pull it from the brine and rinse it off well;
- Soften up the compound butter, and then lather up the bird under the skin (leave big chunks of butter under the skin on the breast meat and thighs/drums). Reserve about 1/2 to 1/3 of the butter for the next step;
- Melt the remaining butter, and brush that all over the skin;
- Stuff the bird's cavity with goodies (for the TG turkey I use apples, cinnamon, onions, rosemary, sage and thyme);
- Roast her at high temp (500?) on the bottom of the oven for the first half hour or so, then lower the temp (350?) and move it up to the center till done.

Comes out with perfect golden brown, just crispy skin. The meat's incredibly moist and the flavor is out of this world. One year, I did one on the smoker in addition to the oven, but for the smoker I didn't stuff the cavity nor did I put butter on the outside of the skin. Instead, I layered bacon strips over the top of the bird. That was a hit.

Seeing this thread is making me want to give this kind of treatment a go with chicken.
 
I guess I won. his was too salty. mine took a long time, surprisingly. the smoker couldn't go over 300 degrees. I shoulda removed the water pan and let the foil tray with the chicken in it do the job, huh? yeah, I really shoulda but the way my WSM smoker was designed, it was easier to just pick up the chicken and get rid of the tray. that worked, 4 hours later.
:smh:
 
I was just at Stater Brothers last night, and they are having a "BBQ Blowout". I loaded up on ground beef (80/20, $1.99/lb), but they also had whole pork shoulder at $0.99/lb, though I don't see it listed in the weekly ad with the ground beef.
 
Back
Top