jerseydevil
I'llPutPenniesOnYourEyes
I think this movie is really going to hinge on if it's a compelling original story, or an unoriginal retread of A New Hope with elements of Empire. Regardless of Luke is bad or good, if the movie is compelling up until that point than we will eat up the reveal. If the movie is lousy or if it's repeating things we've seen in past Star Wars films, the reveal will come off as laughable. As long as Luke doesn't utter the words "I am your father" at any point, we should be good.
True. But the reveal is still massive. It can make a mediocre movie great or terrible.