hokiecat
Super Star
Osgood has a negative GSAA for his career. He feels like the epitome of a guy who rode a great team to a championship as a passenger.Osgood couldn’t touch Quick’s peak but Osgood’s 2008 Cup run was pretty great. 1.55 GAA .930 Sv % 3 SHO.
But what about Ryan Miller? 391 Wins 1 Vezina 1 All Star 1 Silver Medal Started for the 2010 US Olympic team (Quick was the 3rd Goalie).
Miller just had his first year of eligibility in 2024. There's still time for him to get in. But I think Quick will get in ahead of him if both are eligible in the same years.
The Hall has historically been very tough on goalies-- Rogie had to wait forever-- but I think the recent goalie-centric class has indicated that the voters are going to be more fair. It is weird that guys get denied unless they were Roy or Brodeur, but then centers could get in without being another Mario or Wayne.