I seem to have a lot of live albums lately, including all five that are currently in my car. Ideally a live album should have additional energy with a minimal loss of clarity. I like some improvisation, but not so much that it takes away from a song. I want to see a good song choice, maybe with something special thrown in. If the crowd is really into it to the point you can hear them, that is a definite bonus, as are some audible effects in appropriate spots. And unless there is a good reason not to, if a band has the material, every disc better have close to 78 minutes of music on it.
Metallica - Through The Never
The two discs of this album average 50 minutes each, but it is the concert portion of the recent movie of the same name, so I'll allow that. However, there is a part during the end of Enter Sandman where James Hetfield reacts to some incident that is part of the story of the movie. That is highly distracting and probably could have been expunged. Hetfield's voice has lost a step or two (or three), but he can still tear into the lyrics. The song selection is very good, spanning their career and completely ignoring St. Anger. Metallica purists will be happy to see that 9 of the 15 tracks (not counting the intro track) are from the first four albums, including a great rendition of Master Of Puppets with the audience shouting along, powerful playing on the (relatively) slow part, and a nice little guitar solo. The improvisations are pretty good, especially on the first disc, but on the other hand you should not mess with is perfection, and they messed with the intro of For Whom The Bell Tolls. There are a couple moments where some very powerful stage explosions can be heard, which really help sell the experience. I won't penalize the album for the annoying packaging that folds out in multiple directions, but they called the thing Through The Never and didn't put the actual song Through The Never on it. Also, more separation from the Binge And Purge live album, which features Hetfield and Lars Ulrich with 20 fewer years on them at the height of Metallica's career playing a lot of the same songs, could have been had by tacking on some extra tracks after the movie concert. Solid overall, but nothing extraordinary. B.
Firewind - Apotheosis Live 2012
I can't seem to find video of the exact version of Head Up High on the album, and the versions I played on YouTube don't come close to the audio on the CD, so you will have to play it off this German website:
RockHard: Firewind - Head Up High
Ozzy Osbourne's
#1 talent, or perhaps his handlers'
#1 talent, really lies in choosing guitar players. Randy Rhoads, Jake E Lee, Zakk Wylde, and currently Gus G. Gus G may have the misfortune of playing with Ozzy at a point where the man's voice is essentially shot (no idea how Ozzy sounds so much better in 2013 with Sabbath), but he has his own band, Firewind, where his ridiculous guitar playing can be appreciated in a much better setting. Ironically enough, I am not a big fan of Firewind's since-departed vocalist Apollo Papathanasio, who has this small bit of scratchiness in his voice that is just enough to be distracting without being distinctive.
The great thing that Gus G does with Firewind is show off some seriously impressive guitar work without allowing it to overwhelm the songs themselves. What I want in a Firewind live album is to hear him take it further, and in that he definitely delivers, shredding his way here and there but never overdoing it, saving that last gear for the guitar solo track and the instrumental it leads into. The single disc has 17 songs, including a cover of Maniac (yes, that Maniac), which was just ridiculous enough of an idea to be awesome (and has a sweet guitar solo that I am going to guess was not featured in the original). The best songs are fantastic, but some of the others are just average. The band's live performance elevates it to a B+ (Head Up High on its own earning an A or better).