Personally I think a few on this board are too short sighted and do not understand the financial aspect. By the time Chycrhrun's extension comes due we will have had to resign our entire young core, all of which will be due for increases (some very significantly). On top of this we have $11m/season wrapped up in Doughty. Chrychrun, if he pans out like so many on this thread project him to, will be due $12-13m/season minimum. So are you telling me we are going to wrap $23M/season into two defensive players and still be competitive? We could, but it is very much not likely.
Like Helvetica said, if he's that fantastic of a D, then yeah. But I'd expect his upside to be Dougie Hamilton who just got paid $9 x 7. And I'd expect a little less so maybe $8 or $8.5 x 8 and I'd expect that fit fine under the cap.
There is also a big different between a playoff team and cup contender. Blake projects to still be the GM, based on his extension, when Chychrun's extension comes does and knows he needs to add some quality scoring between now and a deep playoff run. He is going to make a more level long term bet given all the factors than Chrychrun unless Chrychrun comes at a reasonable price.
Is there? I would have thought 2012 put that idea to rest. I'd agree that there's a difference between a playoff team and Cup favorite, but that's just opinion. When I see teams like Montreal, Dallas, Nashville, SJ, and the 2012 Kings make the Finals, I'm not sure there's much of a difference.
In any case, the way this team has shown it can play (3 points behind Vegas with only 1 extra game played), I think they're a playoff team this year and SHOULD be competing for the Cup by 25-26, if Byfield turns into a legit
#1 center. If he doesn't, they're screwed anyway.
Sure we could trade players here and there but are we really going to be able to roll with 3 big contracts (projecting one of our youngsters, if not more, pan out)?
If we're projecting to 25-26 when Chychrun would get this hypothetical huge contract, who else would get one? Doughty would still be at $11M but Kopi will be MUCH lower than $10M and I don't see Arvidsson or Iafallo getting a big contract. Peterson? I doubt it. And of all the kids who other than Byfield could possibly be worth a big contract? Kaliyev? Sure, if scores 50+ goals for a couple seasons. Kupari, Durzi, Lizotte? I doubt it. And Byfield will get his contract in 24-25.Seeing what Hughes got, I wouldn't be surprised if he got something similar. But even at $10M I think they can definitely roll with Doughty, Byfied, and Chychrun having big contracts. Also, keep in mind that the cap is likely to start going up more than $1M at some point...I bet it does by 25-26.
Besides, if you manage a team always afraid to commit big money to great players, you'll just keep losing your best players. TB doesn't do that. Vegas doesn't do that. Washington doesn't. Pittsburgh doesn't.
Much of being a long term cup contender comes down to managing long term finances. It's not about getting the best players, but rather about putting together the best team.
Brooks' quote was my signature on LGK for 10 years, so I agree. But that's not about not paying top players. That's about getting guys who say "we before me" and that it's better to have players who will sacrifice individual goals for the team. Getting Chychrun and paying him market value still does that...assuming he's a "we before me" kinda guy.
And to be clear, I don't think I (or anyone else) knows that Chychrun is the the right guy. But running a team you have to take chances and if it's not him who's the top LD on the Kings? Bjornfot? Anderson? IMO, they need someone who's an excellent all-around player and those guys struggle badly with offense.